Accommodating false positives within acoustic spatial capture-recapture, with variable source levels, noisy bearings and an inhomogeneous spatial density
share
Passive acoustic monitoring is a promising method for surveying wildlife populations that are easier to detect acoustically than visually. When animal vocalisations can be uniquely identified on an array of several sensors, the potential exists to estimate population density through acoustic spatial capture-recapture (ASCR). Detections need to be correctly identified and associated across sensors so that capture histories can be built. However, sound classification is imperfect, and in some situations a high proportion of sounds detected on just a single sensor ("singletons") are not from the target species, i.e., are false positives. We present a case study of bowhead whale calls (Baleana mysticetus) collected in the Beaufort Sea in 2010. We propose a novel extension of ASCR that is robust to these false positives by conditioning on calls being detected by at least two sensors. We allow for individual-level detection heterogeneity through modelling a variable sound source level, we model an inhomogeneous call spatial density, and we include bearings with varying measurement error. We show via simulation based on the case study that the method produces near-unbiased estimates when correctly specified. Ignoring source level variation resulted in a strong negative bias, while ignoring inhomogeneous density resulted in severe positive bias. The case study analysis indicated a band of higher call density approximately 30km from shore; 60.7 singletons were estimated to have been false positives.
READ FULL TEXT