Challenges in detecting evolutionary forces in language change using diachronic corpora
share
Newberry et al. (Detecting evolutionary forces in language change, Nature 551, 2017) tackle an important but difficult problem in linguistics, the testing of selective theories of language change against a null model of drift. Having applied a test from population genetics (the Frequency Increment Test) to a number of relevant examples, they suggest stochasticity has a previously under-appreciated role in language evolution. We replicate their results and find that while the overall observation holds, results produced by this approach on individual time series are highly sensitive to how the corpus is organized into temporal segments (binning). Furthermore, we use a large set of simulations in conjunction with binning to systematically explore the range of applicability of the FIT. The approach proposed by Newberry et al. provides a systematic way of generating hypotheses about language change, marking another step forward in big-data driven linguistic research. However, along with the possibilities, the limitations of the approach need to be appreciated. Caution should be exercised with interpreting results of the FIT (and similar tests) on individual series, given the demonstrable limitations, and fundamental differences between genetic and linguistic data. Our findings also have implications for selection testing and temporal binning in general.
READ FULL TEXT